How trends actually spread — and why predictions miss
Hype cycles, S-curves and the difference between a trend that diffuses and one that just gets talked about. A model for reading the next boom.
The question
Every year a handful of things "trend." Some become the defining industry of the decade; most vanish. Is there a way to tell a real diffusion curve from a loud but empty bandwagon before the answer is obvious?
What's happening
Trends are usually reported as sentiment — everyone's excited, so it must be real. But attention and adoption are different quantities, and they move at different speeds.
How it actually works
Most durable technologies follow an S-curve: slow start, fast middle, plateau. Hype follows a spike and often precedes the plateau by years. The gap between the two is where predictions fail.
| Phase | What's true | What gets reported |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | a capability becomes possible | breathless "this changes everything" |
| Peak of hype | expectations outrun reality | the loudest coverage |
| Trough | the hard problems surface | "the trend is dead" |
| Slope of adoption | the boring work compounds | less coverage, more real usage |
| Plateau | it's just how things work now | no coverage at all |
Three mechanisms decide whether a trend survives its own hype:
- Does it have a cost curve it can ride? Technologies that improve along a predictable curve (learning rates, manufacturing volume) keep paying off. Ones that don't, stall at the hype peak.
- Is the demand real or borrowed? Adoption driven by genuine unmet need compounds; adoption driven by scarcity, FOMO or subsidies collapses when those fade.
- Can the bottleneck be moved? Most trends don't die from lack of interest; they die on a physical or economic constraint — the same supply-chain question that decides the AI boom.
So the useful question is not "is this a trend?" but "which curve is it on, and what is the binding constraint?"
A trend is a claim about the future. An S-curve is a claim about a mechanism. Trust the second one more.
What's unknown
- How to measure adoption separately from attention, cheaply. Attention is easy to count; adoption is buried in fragmented data.
- Whether the AI boom is on the steep part of a diffusion S-curve or still near the hype peak. Honestly: I don't know, and anyone who claims certainty is guessing.
- Open: a repeatable scorecard for telling real demand from borrowed demand at the peak. That is the tool I actually want, and I haven't found a good version of it yet.
Reading
- Diffusion-of-innovations literature (the original S-curve work).
- Analyses of past hype cycles, read after the fact, to check what predicted survival.