Methodology
How a claim earns its place
Pramaan publishes claims. This page describes what has to happen to a claim before it does, how sources are judged, and where the practice stops.
The publication's central question is how do we know something is true? That question is answered the same way for every piece: the question is stated, the evidence is shown, the mechanism is traced from the evidence, what remains unknown is named, and the sources are listed so a reader can check the work independently.
The five-part structure
Every piece, from a short explainer to a long investigation, is organised the same way:
- Question — the specific thing being asked or tested, stated so it can be wrong.
- Evidence — the primary material: datasets, documents, measurements, code, records.
- Mechanism — how the evidence produces the result, traced step by step rather than asserted.
- What's unknown — what the evidence does not settle, kept in the body rather than a footnote.
- Sources — the primary material, listed with enough detail to locate it again.
A piece that cannot fill the third and fourth parts is not published. Restating a claim with different words is not research.
Source evaluation
Sources are not weighted equally. Each one is judged on four questions:
- Primary or derived? — original datasets, filings, standards, papers and source code are preferred. Secondary reporting is used to find leads and to check whether a primary source exists, not as the final word.
- Traceable? — the reader must be able to locate the exact document, table, page or commit. A source that cannot be re-found is not cited.
- Current? — the version and date matter. Reports state a data cut-off so a reader knows what was known, and when.
- Interested? — who produced it, and what they wanted. Government bodies, companies and advocacy groups all have reasons to publish what they publish.
Where a figure cannot be traced to its origin, it is not repeated as fact. It is either excluded or presented explicitly as an unverified figure.
Verification
- Numbers are checked against the original source, not against another article that quotes them.
- Calculations are shown where they are not obvious, so a reader can reproduce them.
- Reproducible work — code, notebooks, logs — is published or described precisely enough to rebuild.
- Where verification fails, the piece says so rather than quietly dropping the claim.
Evidence, inference and opinion
These three are kept visibly separate. Evidence is what was measured or read. Inference is what the author concludes from it, and it is offered as an inference. Opinion is marked as such. A reader should be able to tell which of the three they are looking at without being told which one the author prefers.
Limitations
Every piece carries its limits in the open. Common ones are named plainly: a sample too small for the general claim, a single source where two would be better, a period of data that predates a change in the system, a model whose training set could not be inspected, a measurement whose calibration is unknown. A piece with heavy limitations is not a weak piece. A piece that hides them is.
Corrections
Errors are corrected in place and noted, not quietly edited away. The full process, including how to report an error and what a correction notice contains, is on the corrections page. Corrections to a published piece do not remove the piece; they amend the record of it.
AI tools
AI tools may assist with research, editing or drafting. They do not generate findings, invent sources, or stand in for verification. Every piece declares its level of assistance, and a human author is accountable for every sentence. The detailed policy is on the editorial standards page.
Independence
Pramaan carries no sponsored placements and no paid reviews. Advertising, where enabled, is separate from the editorial content and does not affect what is written or how a claim is judged. A trend may be the hook for a piece; it is never the substance of one.
Questions
If something here is unclear, or a piece does not follow it, say so: contact page or [email protected].